29 DAYS AGO • 2 MIN READ

The Identity Tax

profile

Cole Ryan

Writing insights on all things business, life, philosophy, and entrepreneurship.

Every day I watch people transform.

Not gradually. Not subtly. Complete fucking personality switches depending on who's in the room.

Last week I had dinner with this tech founder. Confident, direct, borderline arrogant with me. Then his investors walked in. Suddenly he's deferential, speaking differently, laughing at jokes that aren't funny. Ten minutes later, his team members arrive. Another shift. More authoritative, slightly paternal, using completely different vocabulary.

This man isn't unusual. He's the norm.

I call this the Identity Tax. The massive psychological toll of maintaining multiple versions of yourself for different audiences. Most people pay it without ever realizing what it costs them.

Think about your own day. The professional you at work. The social you with friends. The family you at home. The online you on social media. The dating you with potential partners.

Each requiring its own performance. Its own energy. Its own maintenance.

The Tax isn't just about acting slightly different in various contexts. That's normal adaptation. The Tax kicks in when you're running fundamentally different operating systems depending on the room.

Different values. Different priorities. Different beliefs. Different behaviors. Different realities.

The cost of this constant switching is astronomical. Energy drain. Psychological fragmentation. Decision paralysis. The constant background anxiety of potentially mixing up which version of yourself is appropriate where.

The longer you pay the Tax, the more you lose touch with any genuine center. I've watched people reach their 30s and 40s with absolutely no fucking idea who they actually are underneath all the performances. They've spent so many years being different people in different rooms that they've lost any sense of core identity.

Their authentic self atrophied from lack of use.

When you constantly outsource your identity to your environment, you eventually forget what's yours and what's just an adaptation. Your beliefs become whatever the room requires. Your values become contextual rather than foundational. Your sense of self becomes entirely dependent on external validation.

The alternative path exists, but few take it.

Building a core identity so solid that it doesn't need to fundamentally change across contexts. Developing values that work in all environments. Creating boundaries that don't shift based on who's testing them.

This doesn't mean being rigid or one dimensional. Context matters. Adaptability matters. But there's a world of difference between tactical flexibility and fundamental identity shifting.

The funny thing is, people who pay the highest Identity Tax think they're being sophisticated. Strategic. Socially intelligent. They don't realize they're actually signing up for a lifetime of exhaustion and emptiness.

There rare individuals who maintain consistency across contexts experience a freedom that identity shifters can barely comprehend. The energy never spent on constant recalibration. The clarity that comes from knowing exactly what you stand for. The genuine connections formed when people meet the real you rather than a manufactured version.

In a world obsessed with optionality and keeping all doors open, there's something potent about deciding who you are and showing up as that person consistently. About creating an identity based on internal conviction rather than external adaptation.

Yes, you'll create friction. Yes, you'll sometimes seem out of place. Yes, you'll close certain doors.

But the doors that remain open will be the ones actually worth walking through. The opportunities that align with who you really are. The relationships built on something real.

Stop paying the Tax. Choose consistency over performance. Build from the center out.

Your future self will thank you.

Cole Ryan

Writing insights on all things business, life, philosophy, and entrepreneurship.